What's Your Background?

Posted 17 April 2007 by

Over at After the Bar Closes, Steve Story has set up a poll asking for educational background from PT/AtBC participants. With 90 responses in, the results so far are:
  • PhD Science 32 [35.56%]
  • PhD Humanities 3 [3.33%]
  • BS/BA/Ma Science 39 [43.33%]
  • BS/BA/Ma Humanities 13 [14.44%]
  • High School 3 [3.33%]
  • Lots of Scientific American 0 [0.00%]
  • I Done Readed a Lot on the Internets 0 [0.00%]
  • Check it out.

    42 Comments

    txjak · 17 April 2007

    I couldn't register. No matter what I tried it said the two passwords I entered didn't match. I tried both Firefox and Opera.

    What's up with that?

    PoxyHowzes · 17 April 2007

    Ok, don't give us MS's a box to tick. (Goes away, ticked off...)

    Dean Morrison · 17 April 2007

    I've set up a similar thing on Ben Goldacre's 'Bad Science site to compare with UK'ish people of a similar bent:

    http://badscience.net/forum/viewtopic.php?p=35922#35922

    Wesley R. Elsberry · 17 April 2007

    I interpreted the "Ma" as master's generically.

    Not sure about the failure to register. The IP addresses of banned people would result in that behavior, though, as one class of possible explanation.

    Scott Simmons · 17 April 2007

    And what's a BS Science/Humanities double major to do, hmmm?

    steve s · 17 April 2007

    Yeah, I meant Ma to mean any kind of Master's. That's the second attempt at the poll. The first attempt had a distinction between 'soft science' and 'hard science', which is a distinction I don't believe in, and was stupid to make.

    LEW · 17 April 2007

    add another Bachelors Science. I'm not gonna bother to register and vote.

    Kevin · 17 April 2007

    BA Mathematics!

    and lots of that internet/sci amer/sci fi readings

    Flint · 17 April 2007

    Two science and one humanities degrees. Do I do best two out of three? Do I count only the highest degree?

    Wesley R. Elsberry · 17 April 2007

    I only counted my highest degree.

    Science Avenger · 17 April 2007

    I'm a BS Mathematics that did every research paper in my life on a scientist. Came here to join the fray and learn a little biology. You have not disappointed.

    txjak · 17 April 2007

    Not sure about the failure to register. The IP addresses of banned people would result in that behavior, though, as one class of possible explanation.

    — Wesley R. Elsberry
    I can't imagine why my IP address would be in your list of banned people, unless it was spoofed, mistyped, or misidentified. I'll let it slide for now, since I have alternate paths to register, but it bothers me that my IP address may have been misused. It's a form of identity theft.

    Chip Poirot · 17 April 2007

    Whatever happened to the ** Social ** Sciences?

    steve s · 17 April 2007

    The social sciences are included in the sciences.

    djlactin · 17 April 2007

    Hey! It's a E-lightist ole-boy's club what don't 'low gests to vote. Keeps out us rabble I'm guessin'. How do I register my Ph.D. in Entomology?

    Wesley R. Elsberry · 17 April 2007

    So far, only Karl Priest has turned out to be too, er, challenged to locate and submit a registration for the site. That I know of.

    Tex · 17 April 2007

    I completed several Twelve Step programs. Does that count?

    geogeek · 18 April 2007

    Unwilling to register, MSc (in oceanography).

    And kinda torqued that BS and MS are in one catagory. That was 3.5 years of freakin' hard work, and not an extension of an undergraduate degree.

    djlactin · 18 April 2007

    Looking a bit different now that WEL alerted us!

    PhD Sciences 26 (35.1%)
    PhD Humanities 3 (4.1)
    B/M Sciences 33 (44.6)
    B/M Humanities 10 (13.5)
    HS 2 (2.7)
    Sci Amer 0 (0)
    Internet 0 (0)

    SteveF · 18 April 2007

    BSc, MSc and currently working for a PhD.

    science nut · 18 April 2007

    Overall....the merit badges (degrees) really don't mean much.

    Too bad we can't survey/measure the passion for science or compassion for humanity.

    Don't fret if there isn't a pigeon hole for your situation within this survey. It is what's in your head and not what's on the wall that counts.

    J-Dog · 18 April 2007

    Science Nut - Yes, you are correct dog!

    Dr. Dr. William Dembski is a "PERFECT" example of Degrees Gone Bad - Double PhD smarts, but NO science or love of humanity smarts.

    Dembski = Nothing but a Science Playa Hata.

    Richard Simons · 18 April 2007

    I have also been unable to log on. Going through the 'forgot password' procedure, everything was OK except I never received the new password. Thinking I may have registered using a now-defunct e-mail address, I tried to re-register under a new user name, but it would not allow me to as the address is already in use.

    Several months ago I could go through the log on procedure, apparently with no problems, except when I tried to do anything it complained I was not logged on. (I tried this repeatedly, using Firefox and Internet Explorer.) Like txjak I can't imagine that I was banned for any reason.

    Mike · 18 April 2007

    BSc(Math/Sci), LLB here, but can't be arsed to vote.

    Ben (t.o.o.) · 18 April 2007

    I couldn't get in and don't have time to fiddle with it, but for the record, I've got a Bachelor's in biochemistry and am far enough along a biology Ph.D track that if my project utterly fails tomorrow, I would likely get a consolation masters.

    Mustafa Mond, FCD · 18 April 2007

    Did he tabulate how many FCDs?

    Mustafa Mond, FCD · 18 April 2007

    I only counted my highest degree.

    I had a fever of 102 once when I was young.

    OMB · 18 April 2007

    Where is the Community College drop out option?

    Wesley R. Elsberry · 18 April 2007

    Drat Steve Story for not listing "102 F" among the options!

    harold · 18 April 2007

    I guess I'm rarer than I thought.

    MD long ago, MBA pending in June. Board certified pathologist, three years on faculty at a not-very-famous medical school, then some private practice at what it now a division of a big "biotcech" company, but no longer practicing.

    MBA in finance. Was doing a second major in statistics, but got sucked into a job at a startup, so had to let that go one credit shy of a major.

    No, I'm not making any money yet. May never.

    Sir_Toejam · 18 April 2007

    money...

    what's that again?

    Kevin · 18 April 2007

    Posted by harold on April 18, 2007 8:11 PM (e)

    I guess I'm rarer than I thought.

    MD long ago, MBA pending in June. Board certified pathologist, three years on faculty at a not-very-famous medical school, then some private practice at what it now a division of a big "biotcech" company, but no longer practicing.

    MBA in finance. Was doing a second major in statistics, but got sucked into a job at a startup, so had to let that go one credit shy of a major.

    No, I'm not making any money yet. May never.

    dude that is a sad story.

    I dropped out of college and only went back when I was making stacks of cash.

    by the way where does a BA in math fit in? It is NOT a science. more like the humanities.

    txjak · 18 April 2007

    BA in Math is science more than humanities. I chose science. If you look up
    mathematics in Wikipedia you'll see alot of the science connectedness.

    brightmoon · 18 April 2007

    BS biology (and i still can't type) too late at night for me to think of wrestling with a new password.... sorry

    Paul Flocken · 19 April 2007

    Comment #170754 Posted by Sir_Toejam on April 18, 2007 8:27 PM (e) money... what's that again?

    That's what that science and humanity hata Dumbski has. Barf

    harold · 19 April 2007

    Sir_Toejam -

    "money...

    what's that again?"

    Hopefully I'll be able to let you know in a few years.

    The first step toward recovery was resisting the urge to let the MBA turn into a springboard for PhD in something like stats or economics...

    Pumpkinhead · 20 April 2007

    Overall....the merit badges (degrees) really don't mean much. Too bad we can't survey/measure the passion for science or compassion for humanity. Don't fret if there isn't a pigeon hole for your situation within this survey. It is what's in your head and not what's on the wall that counts.

    I don't know whether you are a Christian or an Evolutionist, but it takes rare insight to challenge the legitimacy of the certificates from the seminaries of evolutionism. I salute you!

    brightmoon · 20 April 2007

    High School 3 [3.33%]
    Lots of Scientific American 0 [0.00%]
    I Done Readed a Lot on the Internets 0 [0.00%]

    actually ..this is worrisome ..we should be looking to give more info to these people not scaring them away

    pumpkinhead .....evolutionism? .....evolution is an easily observed process, deary, not a religion/religious belief

    hoary puccoon · 22 April 2007

    BA, MA, PhD in sociology, with my master's thesis on the sociology of science. Then I became a love slave in the Caribbean, but that's a whole other story.

    Henry J · 23 April 2007

    BS in computer science (what's now called software engineering), with minor in mathematics.

    Henry

    Richard Simons · 23 April 2007

    BSc Agricultural Botany, MSc, PhD Crop Science, then some years later BSc Math/Comp. Sci. For my sins, I am now mainly teaching high school mathematics.

    Administrater · 4 December 2008

    I love it Evaluation status expose accountabilities determin classifications. Commission revenue stand orders auctions overviews.Assements imlementing occasional attention to methods. Thanks is the best
    Administrater said: